Our Story
More than Great Food
Jersey Meatball King- Winner of the 2019, 2021, 2022, 2023 and 2024 Jersey Pizza Joints' Meatball Madness Competition. Our passion for creating exceptional Italian cuisine is matched only by our dedication to providing a memorable dining experience for all our guests. From our carefully curated menu to our warm and inviting ambiance, Jersey Meatball King is where great food meets great moments.
REVIEWS, PUBLICATIONS AND AWARDS
Serving Greatness Since 1985
"Owner John Speciale, from the old neighborhood I grew up in, is an infamous Foodie Savant. Owner of multiple pizzerias over the years, his current place is on the money."
Chris A. - Maywood NJ
"The eggplant parm was the best I ever had and my brother raved about the meatball sandwich!"
​​​​​
​
Gloria A. - Rutherford NJ
"Holy moly just tried mussels and their famous meatballs with another Old World pizza! Whole family devoured and didn't even let me grab extra pics!"
Heather L. - Lyndhurst NJ
"Their pizza is perfectly crispy with rich, flavorful toppings, and the meatballs are hands-down the best—juicy, tender, and packed with authentic Italian flavor. A must-visit for any pizza lover!"
John R. - Englewood NJ
"PizzAmore is a slice of heaven! Their pizza is perfection, with a golden crust and fresh, delicious toppings. The meatballs are out of this world—savory, juicy, and bursting with flavor. Truly the best in town!"
John B. - Carlstadt
"Exceptional flavors, generous portions, and professional service make them a top pick for events big or small!"
Jennifer K. - Fort Lee NJ
"PizzAmore serves pizza perfection! The crust is crispy yet chewy, the sauce is bursting with flavor, and the toppings are always fresh and generously loaded. Hands down, the best pizza around!"
Johnny E - Paramus NJ
"PizzAmore Catering Review
PizzAmore’s catering is a game-changer! From their signature pizzas to mouthwatering meatballs, everything is fresh, flavorful, and perfect for any event."
Angela D.- Wood Ridge NJ
Pogiboy Productions
December 2024
Vern and Gener head to PizzAmore in Carlstadt, NJ to try some of the best meatballs in NJ!! Actually, they've won several awards because of it and we needed to check it out and see what the hype was all about! :) Of course we started with a slice of grandma pizza! It's a square pie and it tasted just as good! It had a nice toast to it! We also ordered the chicken parm and of course, their award winning meatballs! We ordered the meatball parm! For dessert, Vern had the sweet cannoli! Everything about that meatball was super tasty! It's worth the drive and with the cheese and sauce on it, it made it even better! Check them out if you're ever in the area!
KINGSCHRATZ
September 2024
They Claim The Best Meatballs in NJ.
They Might Be Right.
The Sauce Pops!
"The is one of the best meatballs I've ever had!"
DREW R
September 2024
Hey y’all today I went to PizzAmore in Carlstadt which has the best meatballs in NJ. They have won several awards and they did deliver.
COOKING WITH FRANKIE MEATBALLS
September 2024
If you live in New Jersey or close by you have to visit these 2 hidden gems. 2 Time best Meatball Winner back to back Pizza Amore, & Coniglio's Old Fashioned last years winner for pest pizza in New Jersey. Pizza Bowl 3 Winners talk about their love for the food and what they do. Don't miss the real secrets of a New York Egg Cream.
PIZZA, BREWS AND TWO DUDES
JANUARY 2024
Pizza Brews and Two Dudes has officially hit the road! That's right, we're podcasting from the source. Grab a brew and join the dudes as the try the best balls in Jersey with John Speciale and Adolfo, direct from PizzAmore Italian Kitchen in Carlstadt, NJ.
RICH KNOWS NJ
JANUARY 2023
PizzAmore in Carlstadt, NJ : Meatball Sandwich Review
Great spot with old school Italians!
The bread is amazing- toasted!
Looks like they take it... 9.2 !
IT'S EVERYTHING I LOVE!
​
​
​
JERSEY PIZZA JOINTS
FEBRUARY 2022
PizzaBowl2 was a huge success, and we crowned a new Champion for best Pizza in Jersey- Maruca's & Best Balls in Jersey- Pizza Amore Italian Kitchen.